Council bans carol service posters

A Tory council has banned posters for a carol service at a church over fears that non-Christians could be offended.

Chorister Bridget Adams had asked to put up a poster about the event in a local library. She was shocked when her request to publicise the service at All Saints’ Church, in High Wycombe, Buckinghamshire, was refused. An official said it contravened a policy banning notices of a religious, political or sexual nature.

Religious freedom, tolerance, and intolerance
Religious Freedom
The freedom of individuals to believe in, practice, and promote the religion of choice without (government) interference, harrassment, or other repercussions – as long as practices based on, or resulting from, those beliefs do not break the law (e.g. do not encourage or result in fraud, tax evasion, murder, terrorism, acts designed to undermine the government or the constitution, the use of unethical persuasion tactics, etcetera).

Religious Persecution
The practice of discouraging religious freedom and the freedom to express and/or promote all or certain religious beliefs – with repercussions ranging from discrimination and harassment to prevention and prosecution (by legal and/or illegal means). Does not cover legitimate legal measures designed to prevent and/or prosecute illegal practices such as fraud, tax evasion, murder, terrorism, acts designed to undermine the government or the constitution, the use of unethical persuasion tactics, etcetera.

Religious Intolerance
a) Refusing to acknowledge and support the right of individuals to have their own beliefs and related legitimate practices.
b) Also, the unwillingness to have one’s own beliefs and related practices critically evaluated.

The following do not constitute religious intolerance:

  • Excercizing the right to challenge a religion’s claims (e.g. regarding alleged compatibility with, or superiority over, other religious beliefs)
  • Condemning and disallowing illegal practices
  • Rejecting a movement’s claim to be a ”religion” when there is sufficient evidence showing religion is used as a cover (e.g. the Church of Scientology).
  • Religious Tolerance
    Acknowledging and supporting that individuals have the right and freedom to their own beliefs and related legitimate practices, without necessarily validating those beliefs or practices.

    Mrs Adams said: “The librarian said if she accepted one, she would have to take them all. But it was clear it was not about problems with space.

    It was the perceived risk of causing offence.”

    She added: “Surely we can encourage diversity without excluding our own heritage and special traditions?”

    All Saints’ Church is currently without a fulltime vicar and is having its services taken by retired clergymen.

    Mrs Adams is supported by several leaders of non-Christian faiths. Imam Sahidzada Jeelani, of the Wycombe Mission and Mosque Trust, said: “Each faith should be able to celebrate their festivals. I don’t think the poster would be offensive to anyone.”

    Sarup Singh Seehra, president of Gurdwara, the Sikh temple in Wycombe, said: “The joy of Christmas rubs off on other communities. I can’t see how a poster could cause any damage.”

    Mr Seehra, a magistrate who was awarded the MBE for services to the local community, added: “It’s political correctness being taken too seriously.”

    Last night, the county council said the rule had been in place since 1992.

    Margaret Dewar, councillor for libraries, said: “Not all religions celebrate Christmas. People who do not have the responsibility of promoting an inclusive society might see this as nitpicking. But our staff would be criticised if they let an extremist sect publicise its activities.”

    Last week it emerged that Christian imagery has been banished from cards sent out by the Department for Culture.

    And in Birmingham five years ago, the Labour authority replaced the name Christmas with Winterval.


    (Listed if other than Religion News Blog, or if not shown above)
    Evening Standard, UK
    Dec. 12, 2003
    infobrix.-- BROKEN URL -

    Religion News Blog posted this on Saturday December 13, 2003.
    Last updated if a date shows here:


    More About This Subject


    Our website includes affiliate links, which means we get a small commission -- at no additional cost to you -- for each qualifying purpose. For instance, as an Amazon Associate, Religion News Blog earns from qualifying purchases. That is one reason why we can provide this research service free of charge.

    Speaking of which: One way in which you can support us — at no additional cost to you — is by shopping at