Groundhog Almighty

A new movie series from the Museum of Modern Art, “The Hidden God: Film and Faith,” features some pretty brooding stuff. There’s a 1955 Danish movie about a man who thinks he is Jesus Christ, an Ingmar Bergman pastiche about a tormented pastor, a Roberto Rossellini movie about monks. These are, of course, the “intellectual with a capital I” films that audiences might expect at a religious-theme retrospective organized by a major museum. Subtitles and all that fancy stuff.

Shop at Amazon.comdiv>

With one exception. On Thursday, the opening-night feature at the Gramercy Theater, where the series is being presented, was “Groundhog Day,” the 1993 movie starring Bill Murray as a sarcastic television weatherman forced by a twist of fate and magic to relive one day of his life, Feb. 2, over and over.

Since its debut a decade ago, the film has become a curious favorite of religious leaders of many faiths, who all see in “Groundhog Day” a reflection of their own spiritual messages. Curators of the series, polling some 35 critics in the literary, religious and film worlds to suggest films with religious interpretations, found that “Groundhog Day” came up so many times that there was actually a squabble over who would write about it in the retrospective’s catalog.

Harold Ramis, the director of the film and one of its writers, said last week that since it came out he has heard from Jesuit priests, rabbis and Buddhists, and that the letters keep coming. “At first I would get mail saying, ‘Oh, you must be a Christian, because the movie so beautifully expresses Christian belief,’ ” Mr. Ramis said during a conversation on his mobile phone as he was walking the streets of Los Angeles. “Then rabbis started calling from all over, saying they were preaching the film as their next sermon. And the Buddhists! Well, I knew they loved it, because my mother-in-law has lived in a Buddhist meditation center for 30 years and my wife lived there for 5 years.”

In the movie, which enjoys its own seemingly endless cycle of rebirth on cable television, the character played by Mr. Murray is in Punxsutawney, Pa., covering Groundhog Day, Feb. 2, for the fourth year in a row. Frustrated because his career is stalled and by the fact that he can’t seduce his producer, played by Andie MacDowell, he sees his assignment — waiting for a groundhog (or a rat, as Mr. Murray’s character calls it) to see if there will be six more weeks of winter — as the final indignity.

But it isn’t quite. The next day he awakens in the same bed in the same bed-and-breakfast, to the sound of the same tinny clock radio with Sonny and Cher singing “I Got You Babe” and the babblings of the frighteningly cheerful local D.J., to discover that it is Feb. 2 again.

At first, he uses the repetition to his advantage — he learns French poetry, for example, as part of his scheme to seduce the producer. Then he realizes that he is doomed to spend eternity locked in the same place, seeing the same people do the same things every day. It is not until he accepts his fate and sets about helping people (saving a homeless man from freezing to death, for example) that he is released from the eternal cycle of repetition.

Of course, this being an American film, he not only attains spiritual release but also gets the producer into bed.

Angela Zito, a co-director of the Center for Religion and Media at New York University, screens the film for students in her Buddhism class. She said that “Groundhog Day” perfectly illustrates the Buddhist notion of samsara, the continuing cycle of rebirth that Buddhists regard as suffering that humans must try to escape (a belief, Dr. Zito noted, that was missed by executives at Guerlain, who, searching for an exotic name, introduced a perfume called Samsara in the 1980’s, overlooking the negative connotations).

“Groundhog Day,” Dr. Zito said, is a cinematic version of the teachings in Mahayana Buddhism, known as “the greater vehicle.”

“In Mahayana,” she said, “nobody ever imagines they are going to escape samsara until everybody else does. That is why you have bodhisattvas, who reach the brink of nirvana, and stop and come back and save the rest of us. Bill Murray is the bodhisattva. He is not going to abandon the world. On the contrary, he is released back into the world to save it.”

Wow. So can anyone (a newspaper reporter?) be a bodhisattva?

“I would call that a Napoleon complex,” Dr. Zito said with a sniff. “There is only one bodhisattva, and that is the Dalai Lama.”

Some theologians see much less Buddhism in the story than Judaism. Dr. Niles Goldstein, rabbi of the New Shul congregation in Greenwich Village and author of “Lost Souls: Finding Hope in the Heart of Darkness” (Bell Tower, 2002), said he finds Jewish resonance in the fact that Mr. Murray’s character is rewarded by being returned to earth to perform more mitzvahs — good deeds — rather than gaining a place in heaven, which is the Christian reward, or achieving nirvana, the Buddhist reward. He has not used the movie as an allegory for his congregation, he said, but he might now.

“The movie tells us, as Judaism does, that the work doesn’t end until the world has been perfected,” Rabbi Goldstein said.

But wait. Michael Bronski, a film critic for The Forward who teaches a course in Jewish film history at Dartmouth, said he sees strong elements of not only Jewish but also Christian theology. “The groundhog is clearly the resurrected Christ, the ever hopeful renewal of life at springtime, at a time of pagan-Christian holidays,” he said, adding: “And when I say that the groundhog is Jesus, I say that with great respect.”

The Rev. James Martin, a Jesuit priest and an associate editor of America, the National Catholic Weekly, didn’t quite see the groundhog as Christ-like. Referring to the Murray character, he said, “You do, however, very clearly see the deadness of his life at the beginning of the movie.” After the self dies, he added, “what is reborn is this new person resurrected from his comatose way of looking at the world.”

Mr. Ramis, who was raised Jewish, said he feels like a Buddhist, but does not practice any religion. “Although I am wearing meditation beads on my wrist,” he said. “But that’s because I’m on a Buddhist diet. They’re supposed to remind me not to eat, but actually just get in the way when I’m cutting my steak.”

The connection between Judaism and Buddhism, he said, is a strong one, adding that many Buddhists in the United States started out as Jews. “There is a remarkable correspondence of philosophies and even style between the two,” he said.

Yogis, Jesuits and psychoanalytic practitioners have told Mr. Ramis that they feel a strong spiritual kinship with the message they see in the film. In the case of the psychoanalysts, he said, “it’s the `we keep reliving the same old patterns over and over again until we gain the right to free ourselves’ thing.”

And in Washington, a branch of the Chinese spiritual movement Falun Dafa, also known as Falun Gong, has used the movie to instruct members in its belief that the spiritual self is not allowed to move to higher levels until it learns from past mistakes. (Dr. Zito said that makes sense, because Falun Gong draws many beliefs from Buddhism.) Some Wiccans also point to the film as particularly important to their beliefs, because Groundhog Day — the day itself — is one of the four “greater sabbats” that divide the year at the midpoints between the solstices and equinoxes. Several Web sites devoted to Wicca call the movie required viewing.

Scott Prendergast, a 32-year-old actor and director who said his film career was inspired in part by movies like “Groundhog Day,” said he noticed the spiritual element in the film from the first. (Mr. Prendergast has two short films currently showing on the Sundance Channel.)

“No one comes down and issues this formal command, and so he doesn’t know, and the audience doesn’t know, why this day is repeating, but it is,” Mr. Prendergast said. “And that’s why it is appealing to so many different religions. He faces this existential test, but he does not know it’s a test, and he doesn’t know what the results will be.”

A survey of religious leaders in Punxsutawney turned up little excitement about the movie’s message. One, Charlene King, the director of the Child Evangelical Fellowship of Jefferson County in Punxsutawney, said her organization does not use the movie to teach spiritual values. “We stick pretty much to Scripture,” Ms. King said.

Dr. Zito couldn’t think of any other obviously Buddhist movies off the top of her head. How about the original “Star Wars” trilogy, with its message of redemption? “Lord of the Rings”? Or, say, “Shampoo,” whose main character — a Lothario hairdresser played by Warren Beatty — makes the same mistake over and over until he recognizes it and considers changing his ways?

” `Shampoo’?” Dr. Zito said. “I don’t think so. Warren Beatty probably knows he’ll never be saved.”

Vacation? Short break? Day trip? Get Skip-the-line tickets at GetYourGuide.


(Listed if other than Religion News Blog, or if not shown above)
The New York Times, USA
Dec. 6, 2003
Alex Kuczynski

Religion News Blog posted this on Monday December 8, 2003.
Last updated if a date shows here:


More About This Subject


Our website includes affiliate links, which means we get a small commission -- at no additional cost to you -- for each qualifying purpose. For instance, as an Amazon Associate, Religion News Blog earns from qualifying purchases. That is one reason why we can provide this research service free of charge.

Speaking of which: One way in which you can support us — at no additional cost to you — is by shopping at