Some want to use conference to test LDS authority
Baptist street preachers, never fearful of stirring the pot as they
preach to LDS Church members, say they plan to sermonize on Main Street
Plaza this weekend as The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
marks its 173rd Semi-annual General Conference.
“There’s a good chance will we be going to the plaza on Sunday,” street
preacher Lonnie Pursifull said. “Our permission comes straight from
Pursifull, Utah director of the World Wide Street Preachers
Fellowship, said about 30 preachers plan to evangelize at general
conference. While most preachers stick to the public sidewalks in front
of the church’s new Conference Center, Pursifull said some are
preparing to head for the plaza Sunday to test the LDS Church’s
authority to control speech there.
Late Thursday, Randall Wenger, attorney with Clymer & Musser
Attorneys at Law based in Lancaster, Pa., sent a letter to City
Attorney Ed Rutan and Salt Lake City Police Department detective Jay
Rhoades warning the city to refrain from arresting or hindering the
preachers on the plaza.
“It is an unconstitutional abuse of authority to allow private
citizens, even the Mormon Church, to direct law enforcement officers to
deny First Amendment-protected demonstrators access to traditional
public fora,” the letter stated.
Saturday will commence the first general conference since the
Salt Lake City Council voted to give the LDS Church authority to
regulate behavior and speech on Main Street Plaza, which was formerly a
public forum as part of Main Street downtown.
That vote, which traded the city’s public access easement,
including guarantees of free speech and expression, to the church for
two acres of land in Glendale where a community center will be built,
is being challenged by several plaintiffs, represented by the American
Civil Liberties Union.
The plaintiffs claim the city helped “establish” the LDS Church
by giving up free speech and public access on the plaza. The church had
wanted to control the plaza so it could ban street preachers and others
who might be critical of the church in the shadow of its world
headquarters and Salt Lake Temple.
Still, many, including the ACLU, say the deal is unconstitutional.
And the street preachers may test it this weekend.
As property owner, the church can’t kick the preachers off the
plaza. But it can call city police officers, who have the authority to
make the preachers leave, in handcuffs if necessary.
Pursifull said an arrest could be the trigger for another lawsuit
against the city’s decision to give the church control over the plaza.
Pursifull said the street preachers are seeking to keep any legal
action they might take separate from the ACLU’s suit.
Prior to receiving the letter, Rutan said city officials had met
to discuss what action the city should take if street preachers did
show up on the plaza. Those discussions, Rutan said, were similar to
discussions the city, along with its police department, has every LDS
Church general conference.
“We just kind of had some brief conversations going through the
usual preparations,” he said. “This is not the first time conference
has been held.”
The initial Main Street Plaza suit came after the city sold a
block of Main Street to the LDS Church in 1999 for $8.1 million. In
that sale the city reserved a public-access easement across the plaza
but gave the church the authority to prohibit protests and
proselytizing, certain dress and other things the LDS Church finds
The ACLU of Utah sued Salt Lake City over the restrictions, and
the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said the city cannot have public
access on the plaza while forbidding certain types of speech there.
Next the city reached its current deal to make the plaza entirely
private and forsake guarantees of free expression and pedestrian
passage on it.
Thursday the ACLU of Utah, with a half-dozen plaintiffs, filed
suit challenging the community center deal on the basis that it takes
away constitutional guarantees of free expression and was too favorable
for the LDS Church.
We appreciate your support
Our website includes affiliate links, which means we get a small commission — at no additional cost to you — for each qualifying purpose. For instance, as an Amazon Associate Religion News Blog earns from qualifying purchases. That is one reason why we can provide this service free of charge.