Jack Straw: Muslim courts will always remain subservient to English law

“No court will endorse an agreement which conflicts with English law”

Muslim courts will always remain ‘subservient’ to English law, Jack Straw declared last night.

In a speech to an Islamic conference, the Justice Secretary said the arguments against creating a parallel system of Sharia law in Britain were ‘overwhelming’.

His remarks come less than a week after one of his junior ministers, Bridget Prentice, appeared to clear Islamic courts to deal with family and divorce disputes, including how a Muslim couple divide their money and property and who gets the children.

Mr Straw said that – while courts could consider a Sharia ruling – they would make their own judgments on the welfare of the children.

The Shar’ia (Islamic law) specifies the obligatory acts (fardh), the omission of which constitutes sin, and forbidden acts (haram), the practice of which constitutes sins. Everything else, not derived from these principles, are said to be permissable (mubah).
Throughout the world Sharia has led (and continues to lead) to human rights violations, including cruel and unusual punishments (e.g. death penalty by stoning, hanging, or beheading. Amputations of hands and/or feet. Public executions, and etcetera).
Somali Islamists stone a woman to death (Oct. 28, 2008 — that’s this century, folks).

Comments & resources by ReligionNewsBlog.com

Mr Straw, who is also Lord Chancellor, added: ‘It is ultimately up to the court to decide whether the agreement complies with English law.  No court will endorse an agreement which conflicts with English law.’

In the strongest passage of last night’s speech, he continued: ‘There is nothing whatever in English law that prevents people abiding by Sharia principles if they wish to, provided they do not come into conflict with English law.

‘There is no question about that.  But English law will always remain supreme, and religious councils subservient to it.’

Mr Straw earlier told the audience that ‘many dreadful things have been done in the name of mainstream religions.  Barbaric practices such as stoning have been — quite wrongly — justified by reference to Islam, for instance’.

He added: ‘I am firm in disagreeing with those who say that Sharia law should be made a separate system in the UK.  And there has been much misinformation in recent weeks about this issue.

‘There are some countries which do have within their systems of law separate courts to deal with issues of inheritance and family law for different faith groups, such as India and Egypt.

‘But we do not in the UK and there are overwhelming arguments about why we should not move down this path.’

Under certain circumstances, religious courts can act as arbitrators in personal disputes, Mr Straw said.

But he added: ‘Crucially, any member of a religious community — or indeed, any other community — has the right to refer to an English court, particularly if they feel pressured or coerced to resolve an issue in a way in which they feel uncomfortable.’

His speech will be seen as an attempt to end nine months of controversy over the role of tribunals run according to Islamic strictures.

In February, Downing Street slapped down the Archbishop of Canterbury when he suggested the rise of Sharia law seemed ‘unavoidable’.

But in July, Lord Phillips, who has since retired as Lord Chief Justice, said Sharia principles could be the basis for resolving family and business disputes.

– Source: Jack Straw: Muslim courts will ALWAYS remain subservient to English law, James Slack, Daily Mail (UK), Oct. 30, 2008 — Summarized by Religion News Blog
Vacation? Short break? Day trip? Get Skip-the-line tickets at GetYourGuide.


(Listed if other than Religion News Blog, or if not shown above)

Religion News Blog posted this on Friday October 31, 2008.
Last updated if a date shows here:


More About This Subject


Our website includes affiliate links, which means we get a small commission -- at no additional cost to you -- for each qualifying purpose. For instance, as an Amazon Associate, Religion News Blog earns from qualifying purchases. That is one reason why we can provide this research service free of charge.

Speaking of which: One way in which you can support us — at no additional cost to you — is by shopping at Amazon.com.