Polygamous sect fathers ask judge to return seized kids

Three FLDS fathers have asked a judge in San Antonio to return their children, saying Texas authorities acted in a “blunderbuss” fashion to remove them from a polygamous sect’s ranch.

The fathers – James Dockstader, Rulon Keate and LeLand Keate – say they all have monogamous marriages to women who were of legal age when they married. Each family lived in separate residences at the ranch and there is no evidence their children were physically or sexually abused, they say.

Their habeas corpus petition challenges the “illegal detention” of some of their children, who range in age from 1 to 9 and are in shelters in San Antonio.

Texas, they say, has “ripped apart families and illegally continues to damage and harm hundreds of children and parents” by “running roughshod” over their constitutional rights to due process and equal protection.

Texas authorities have custody of 464 children taken in early April from the YFZ Ranch, whose residents are members of the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. The state argues the children were at risk because of the sect’s polygamous, communal lifestyle and a “prevalent” practice of underage marriage.

Theologically, Mormonism in turn is a cult of Christianity
Theologically, the FLDS is also considered to be a cult of Christianity
Sociologically, the FLDS is a high-demand, high-control, destructive cult. Among other things, it teaches and practices polygamy, breaks up families and marriages, and has engaged in arranged and forced marriages.
In contrast to the Mormon Church, the FLDS practices a more original version of Mormonism. Mormonism’s doctrines constantly change in response to outside pressure and realities.

Comments & resources by ReligionNewsBlog.com

At least three other actions are pending before different courts in Texas that make arguments similar to those of the three fathers, who are represented by attorneys Amy Hennington, Kent Schaffer and Gerald Goldstein and his law firm.

The men object they were not individually notified of the state action nor allowed to argue during a “chaotic” two-day hearing in mid-April, at which a judge ordered the children to remain in state custody.

The attorneys contend their ability to fairly represent the families was “severely” compromised, especially for lawyers seated in an overflow auditorium.

Mothers being sheltered at the San Angelo Coliseum were not able to participate.

Tom Green County Judge Barbara Walther discouraged attorneys from cross-examining witnesses by saying “bless you” when one attorney said he had no questions, the lawyers note, and telling another who did that it was “unfortunate.”

“At no point during the proceedings was there any consideration of [each father’s] home and their abilities as parents,” the filing said.

Such an approach is “expressly condemned” by the U.S. Supreme Court, in a ruling centered on presumptions about how parents might act versus how they do act, it adds.

The men argue there was no evidence that their children were in immediate danger, and say the removal has interfered with their families’ religious liberties.

FLDS members believe they should live as a religious community insulated from secular influences. Fathers are regarded as priests who lead worship services – which is now impossible.

The state “has no lawful justification for prohibiting these children from practicing their religion,” the filing said.

The state must prove that harm will result from conduct – not belief – that is imminent, not speculation about what might happen decades from now, it adds.

Child welfare workers “cannot justify taking these children from their parents because the state disapproves of their religion, and it cannot condition their return to their families on their parents’ abandonment of their religious beliefs,” it said.

The men and their wives have the “same rights as any other citizen to marry, procreate and have a family,” the filing said.

“The fact that one of their neighbors had become pregnant before age 18 hardly establishes an immediate threat in [their] homes.”

Vacation? Short break? Day trip? Get Skip-the-line tickets at GetYourGuide.


(Listed if other than Religion News Blog, or if not shown above)

Religion News Blog posted this on Thursday May 15, 2008.
Last updated if a date shows here:


More About This Subject


Our website includes affiliate links, which means we get a small commission -- at no additional cost to you -- for each qualifying purpose. For instance, as an Amazon Associate, Religion News Blog earns from qualifying purchases. That is one reason why we can provide this research service free of charge.

Speaking of which: One way in which you can support us — at no additional cost to you — is by shopping at Amazon.com.