Polygamists hit the Web in search of sister-wives

NEW YORK — Albert Morrison is a religious man. He prays, he reads the Bible and says he has a deep connection with Jesus. It is this devotion that helps explain why Albert and his wife, Sarah, are searching for a second wife.

“David, Abraham, Jacob, Solomon — they all had multiple wives,” he said, referring to the four of the Bible’s most revered prophets. “The Bible never banned polygamy, it glorified it.”

The Morrisons are part of a group of Evangelical Christian polygamists who believe that polygamy, the practice of taking more than one wife, is spiritually and even economically more favorable than monogamy.

Taking multiple wives is essential for them, but finding them isn’t easy. The Morrisons, who live in eastern Idaho, do not have a church or a religious community and have very limited social networks through which they can meet potential spouses, or sister-wives. All this is complicated by the fact that polygamy is illegal in the United States. So, the Morrisons and a growing number of polygamists like them are looking where millions of people seeking companionship, love and sex have ventured: the Internet.

“Sarah and I wish there were as many legitimate avenues for finding a spouse as there are for traditional relationships,” said Morrison. “But, that’s the beauty of the Internet. It eases the loneliness of being a Christian polygamist. You can connect with people all across the country.”

Albert, 44, who drives a truck, and Sarah, 31, a manager at a nursing home, have been married for six years. They started looking for a third spouse three years ago and put up ads on various sites like SoulfulHarmony.com, 2Wives.com and ChristianMarriage.com. Since then, they have heard from people in nearly every state and Canada.

Their personal ad reads like any other on the site: “Loving couple seeks to share life with like-minded woman. We don’t care what color your skin is, we want to get to know your heart.”

“It is not about the sex,” Albert said. “It’s about companionship.”

Evangelical Christian polygamists have no connection to the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints (FLDS), an offshoot of the Mormon Church that openly practices polygamy. While polygamy experts say there are about 35,000 FLDS polygamists in the United States, there is no exact number for Christian polygamists. Mark Henkel, the founder of TruthBearer.org, a Christian evangelical pro-polygamy organization, said that the polygamist movement has been growing steadily for the past 12 years. Henkel says there are less than 50,000 Christian polygamists, but experts cannot substantiate this.

“The advent of the Internet really put Christian polygamy on the map,” said Henkel, adding that his Website and its sister site, 2Wives.com, received the most number of hits and new members in August 2006, when Warren Jeffs, the fugitive “prophet” of the FLDS, was caught by the FBI. Jeffs was later convicted of being an accomplice to the rape of a 14-year-old church member.

“The bad publicity was good for business, so to speak,” said Henkel. “People wanted to find out what separated us from them.” While both groups are polygamous, Christian polygamists are scattered across the country, whereas the FLDS is concentrated in Colorado City, Ariz.; Hilldale, Utah; and most recently, El Dorado, Texas.

Both groups, however, share the quality of being extremely conservative in their views about morality, but unconventional in their views about what defines a marriage. Both groups also have a notorious reputation for underage marriage and domestic violence. John Llewellyn, a former deputy sheriff in Utah who has investigated and written about polygamy, says he has not seen cases of exploitation of minors associated with pro-polygamy sites.

Pastor Don Milton, an ordained minister in Arizona who preaches polygamy from his Web site ChristianMarriage.com, says that followers of his brand of Christianity and users of his Web site are decent and upstanding adults. “Christian polygamy attracts extremely religious adults with a desire to live God’s word,” he said.

Milton hopes to open a church that will be accepting of people who choose polygamous lifestyles. “We can’t openly preach polygamy because it’s against the law, but we will welcome families who engage in the lifestyle,” he said.

Until then, the Internet is his pulpit. His Web site has helped create a virtual community for people who don’t have one in the real world. He runs a small personals section on his site, but generally tries not to get involved with matching people up, fearing imprisonment. Still, he makes an enthusiastic pitch for the skeptic.

“Of course a woman would want to marry a married man,” Milton said. “A single guy is an unknown quantity, whereas a married guy has a track record.”

But, not all single women feel that way. Milton said that couples are desperate to find single women, but single women generally want single men.

So goes the challenge that Margie and Lee Sharp have been facing. Margie, 32, and Lee, 36, live in Loranger, La., and have been looking for a religious, white woman to help raise their four boys.

The Sharps say they are born-again Christians who made the decision to practice polygamy after closely studying the Bible. “We prayed and prayed and prayed about it and God put it in our hearts to practice the Biblical lifestyle,” Margie Sharp said.

She goes to church twice a week and started looking for a sister-wife three years ago. When she began telling members of her non-denominational church in Louisiana about her search, some members started calling her wicked and immoral. Her family told her she was crazy and her neighbors thought she was odd. “So, I turned to the Internet, it was the only place I could be honest and not be laughed at,” she said.

Although she and her husband have found solace in cyberspace, Margie says, they haven’t found a sister-wife. “I want someone who will be my best friend and will give me a baby girl,” Margie says, ticking off the criteria that make the search for a soulmate difficult. “We’re not into homosexual threesomes; we don’t drink, or smoke or gamble,” she said. “We’re looking for marriage; we’re not dating and don’t believe in pre-marital sex”.

The Morrisons have also experienced the highs and lows of Internet dating. “We met one woman who was 97 years old,” Albert said with a chuckle. “But she acted like she was 20!” Last year, they met a more appropriately aged woman from Alabama who might have married them, but neither they nor she could relocate.

“We’re just going to keep praying and keep searching the Internet,” Albert said. “God will find someone for us when he wills.”

Vacation? Short break? Day trip? Get Skip-the-line tickets at GetYourGuide.


(Listed if other than Religion News Blog, or if not shown above)

Religion News Blog posted this on Saturday February 23, 2008.
Last updated if a date shows here:


More About This Subject


Our website includes affiliate links, which means we get a small commission -- at no additional cost to you -- for each qualifying purpose. For instance, as an Amazon Associate, Religion News Blog earns from qualifying purchases. That is one reason why we can provide this research service free of charge.

Speaking of which: One way in which you can support us — at no additional cost to you — is by shopping at Amazon.com.