Irish Times, Jan. 22, 2003
The Church of Scientology has a deep-rooted objection to conducting a debate in court on the merits of religious practices, the High Court was told yesterday.
Mr Michael Collins SC, for the church, objected to the hearing of evidence from a Canadian professor of sociology on the grounds that admitting such evidence could lead to the 11-day case, taken by a woman against his client, continuing until the end of February.
Earlier, Mr Collins said many religious practices had the potential for stress but the court could not go into those even if they did cause stress.
Mr Collins said he understood that the plaintiff’s side intended to call about four or five expert witnesses, a total of about 10 witnesses yet to be called on behalf of Ms Johnston. This could mean the case would last several weeks and would not finish until the end of February. He would then be compelled to call upon witnesses to give counter evidence, Mr Collins said.
Responding to Mr Justice Peart on whether he was obliged to accept that scientology was a religion, Mr Collins said the church believed every human being had a soul and an immortal existence. The court was told there were 2,000 churches in 110 countries.
In evidence, Prof Kent said he had studied new religions and cults and had written extensively on the subject. He had interviewed about 50 former scientologists. He described the structure and organisation of scientology as very complicated with “international management” at the top. Ireland and Britain had one joint body while the Dublin Mission would be described as being at the lowest level of the church.
Asked by Mr Michael Cush SC, for Ms Johnston, if there was a general body of complaints about the church’s dianetics auditing policy, Prof Kent said there was and he was also aware of individual testimony about its harmful effects.
Possibly Related Products
Our website includes affiliate links, which means we get a small commission — at no additional cost to you — for each qualifying purpose. For instance, as an Amazon Associate Religion News Blog earns from qualifying purchases. That is one reason why we can provide this service free of charge.