WASHINGTON — Sen. Charles Grassley, the top Republican on the Senate Finance Committee, is preparing another round of letters to Christian television ministries, prodding them to answer questions about their spending and the way they are governed, a spokeswoman said Thursday.
At the same time, an aide to the committee’s Democratic chairman indicated it would be in the ministries’ best interest to cooperate with the Iowa Republican’s investigation.
Two of the ministers, Creflo Dollar and Bishop Eddie Long, both based in suburban Atlanta, have refused to cooperate. Missouri-based Joyce Meyer Ministries pledged full cooperation and has turned over documents. A Texas ministry led by Kenneth Copeland also has turned over information, although the extent of the group’s cooperation isn’t clear.
Grassley started his probe of the ministries in early November but has met resistance from some of the six ministries he has questioned.
The senator’s latest attempt to get answers from the holdouts comes as criticism of his probe is mounting within the evangelical establishment. The flagship magazine of the movement, Christianity Today, editorialized this month that the Grassley probe amounted to “oversight overstep” that risked delving improperly into theology.
Others — including the head of the Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability and the editor of Charisma, another evangelical magazine — still support Grassley but say they’ve been pressured to change their positions.
The targeted ministries have gotten advice from Jay Sekulow, a well-connected Washington lawyer in evangelical and Republican circles, according to two sources with knowledge of the talks who requested anonymity because they are not authorized to speak publicly about them. Sekulow heads the American Center for Law and Justice, founded by televangelist Pat Robertson.
A statement issued by the center said: “While the ACLJ is concerned about the constitutional issues raised by the inquiry, it will not be making any appearances on behalf of any of the ministries before the Senate Finance Committee and is not going to comment further on what counsel it has given or not given to any of the ministries involved.”
– The Bible, 1 Timothy 6:3-10 NIV
In early November, Grassley sent letters to six Christian ministries seeking answers to dozens of questions about salaries, mansions, private jets, expensive furniture and board makeup. While Grassley has emphasized his interest lies not in doctrine but whether tax laws are being followed, several ministries have complained that religious freedoms are being endangered. They say the IRS, not a Senate committee, is the proper forum for investigating complaints that Grassley says prompted his probe.
The ministries — all of whom preach a “prosperity gospel” that God wants his followers to flourish financially — also have insisted that they follow IRS rules on how their spend their donors’ dollars.
Under IRS guidelines, ministers may receive “reasonable” compensation but cannot enrich themselves through their nonprofits.
The two remaining groups, one led by Texas-based faith healer Benny Hinn and the other by Randy and Paula White of Tampa, Fla., have been in touch with Grassley’s office but have not indicated whether they are cooperating or fighting.
Jill Gerber, Grassley’s finance committee spokeswoman, said the the follow-up letters would go out in the next few weeks to ministries that have raised concerns or not responded. Gerber said the letters will describe Congress’ authority and duty to investigate and evaluate laws over which it has legislative authority — in this case, tax-exempt policy.
“It’s been extremely rare for tax-exempt groups to decline to cooperate with his requests for information,” she said in a statement to The Associated Press. “Tax-exempt groups usually work to answer questions from a leader of the Senate committee that sets tax policy. Sen. Grassley hopes that these groups will be similarly cooperative with this inquiry.”
Democratic Sen. Max Baucus of Montana, the finance committee chairman, has not commented publicly on Grassley’s investigation. But Carol Guthrie, communications director for the committee’s Democratic staff, said this week Baucus is aware of the investigation, and suggested that the ministries ought to cooperate.
“Customarily, people come to recognize the wisdom of responding to requests by senior members of the Finance Committee, and particularly by Senator Grassley, before a subpoena becomes necessary,” she said.
Grassley has said he doesn’t believe he’ll need subpoenas. But if he seeks them, he would need Baucus’s backing. Grassley has previously pointed out that when he was committee chairman, he worked well with Baucus.
Gaining support of the Democratic chairman would not only give the investigation added heft, it would deflect criticism like that of Dollar, the most outspoken critic among the ministers under scrutiny.
Dollar said last week on the Fox Business Network that it was Grassley, and not the committee, who was conducting the investigation of him and the other preachers.
We appreciate your support
One way in which you can support us — at no additional cost to you — is by shopping at Amazon.com.
Our website includes affiliate links, which means we get a small commission — at no additional cost to you — for each qualifying purpose. For instance, as an Amazon Associate Religion News Blog earns from qualifying purchases. That is one reason why we can provide this service free of charge.