Skip to main content.
Religion News Blog is a non-profit service providing academics, religion professionals and other researchers with religion & cult news
ReligionNewsBlog

Religion news articles about religious cults, sects, world religions, and related issues

Navigation:
A Random Image
Gilbert Deya Ministries:

Justice Ryder’s Deya Ruling a Persuasive Precedent?

The Nation, Kenya
Dec. 20, 2004
Desma Nungo
allafrica.com

ReligionNewsBlog.com • Item 9738 • Posted: Monday December 20, 2004  

Click here... More articles on this topic: Gilbert Deya Ministries

The epitome of the battle over parentage in Kenya was no doubt in the Gilbert Deya Ministries saga.

The saga, first uncovered by the United Kingdom Police and Investigators, led to the filing of charges in a Family Division Court in the United Kingdom against Gilbert Deya, a Kenyan citizen resident in the United Kingdom.

This was in relation to a one-year-old boy allegedly claimed by Deya as his child.

After intensive investigations and submissions before a Family Division Court in the United Kingdom, Justice Ryder, the sitting umpire therein, made findings against Gilbert Deya.

The Judge in appreciating the fact that motive is one of the basic human avarices, ordered that the biological parents of the child be traced.

Kenyan courts, like the courts in all Common Law jurisprudential settings, use their judicial precedents. Also known as case law, judicial precedent refers to law pronounced by the judges and this explains the common reference to judge made laws.

Judicial precedents are usually found in law reports of the respective jurisdictions. This application of judicial precedents stems from the legal doctrine of precedent.

The principle behind the doctrine of precedent is that in each case, the judge applies existing principles of law by following the example or precedent of earlier decisions. In this way, the judge may expand and develop the law.

Pursuant to the said principle underlying this doctrine of judicial precedent, like cases should be decided in a like manner, unless the purportedly similar case has been otherwise distinguished by a party thereto.

The phrase ‘like cases’ in this sense has been used to mean similar cases, in the sense of the facts of the case, or in the sense of the cause of action therein, notwithstanding the respective parties thereto.

The principle has been widely applied in England jurisprudence, with a logical principal rationale of ensuring certainty in the legal process.

Other advantages that may be attributed to case law include but are not limited to flexibility and growth, practicability and the detailed nature of case law as deduced from many judgments on a particular legal principle.

Kenya being a former British colony, has widely applied the same principle in its courts of law, so that decisions of its higher courts are usually in principle binding on the lower courts.

The principle has characterised Kenyan jurisprudential setting so that advocates in Kenyan courts are usually expected to submit judicial authorities in support of their points of reasoning.

The umpires sometimes go as far as failing to make a determination as to certain noble issue raised by such advocates if the same are not supported by decided authorities.

This thus shows how significantly the doctrine is applied in the Kenyan legal process.

There is considerable similarity of facts and circumstances between the England trial of Pastor Deya and that of his spouse here in Kenya.

What then may be the effect of this decision of Justice Ryder of the foreign court in the Kenyan legal setting?

The general principle has been that courts do not have extraterritorial jurisdiction, meaning that a decision made by a court in one country has no application in the courts of another.

There is, however, one exception so that commonwealth countries have a common tradition, having been at one time British colonies.

The Kenyan legal system having been modelled on the English legal system, there is a similarity in the principles of law applied in these two countries.

Because of this, the decision of one commonwealth country like England, though not binding on Kenya, is of persuasive authority.

In the premise, Justice Ryder’s ruling in the almost similar case could be of persuasive authority in the pending Kenyan case to the extent that the court in Kenya may consider it when making its final determination.

But it must, however, be appreciated that the said decision is not binding on the Kenyan court but only of persuasive authority in trying to reach a just determination in the Kenyan case.


What You Can Do From Here

Read More Articles On These Topics
more religion news aboutmore Religion News Blog articles about
Share, Blog About, Bookmark, or Email This Article
Subscribe
Read Another Article
Find Related Information
cult research search enginecountercult information Use our custom search engines to find additional research resources on religions and cults
Find Related Books


Most Popular Today


Share This Article

To share this page simply copy and paste one of these URL's:





Counter Cult Search

Search for information about (religious) cults, cult-like organizations, -- as well as paranormal-, New Age, and pseudoscientific claims -- across 260+ websites, blogs and forums dedicated to cult research, spiritual abuse, ex-cult counseling & support.


Note: results are listed on another domain -- CounterCultSearch.com -- from which you can easily return here.


Apologetics Search

Search for apologetics articles, books, videos, and other research resources across 135 Christian apologetics websites and blogs.


Note: results are listed on another domain -- ApologeticsSearch.com -- from which you can easily return here.

About Religion News Blog
Religion News Blog (RNB), published by Apologetics Index, highlights news items and other resources on world religions, cults, religious sects, alternative religions and related issues. RNB's non-profit news clipping service is used by - among others - Christian apologists, countercult professionals, anticult organizations, cult experts, teachers, religion professionals, reporters and other researchers.

Home
Latest Headlines
RSS news feed [?]
Headlines by Email
News Trackers
Free content for your site
About RNB
Privacy Policy
Contact RNB
Link to RNB
Advertise on RNB
Apologetics Index
Cult FAQ
Apologetics Search Engine
CounterCult Search Engine