Skip to main content.
A non-profit service providing academics, religion professionals and other researchers with religion & cult news

Religion news articles about religious cults, sects, world religions, and related issues

Home | About RNB Related: Cult FAQ | Cult Experts | Apologetics Index | Cult Information Search Engine
More articles about: Jehovah's Witnesses:

Judge: Sisters may pursue church case • Wednesday February 26, 2003

The Telegraph, Feb. 26, 2003
By ANDREW WOLFE, Telegraph Staff

NASHUA Two sisters can pursue their claims that elders from their Jehovahs Witness congregation in Wilton ignored their mothers complaints of sexual abuse, a judge has ruled.

The sisters say that church elders failed to report their fathers abuse or do anything to stop it. They also claim that church policy and practices shield abusers from prosecution.

The church disputes that the elders were made aware of the abuse at the time.

Hillsborough County Superior Court Judge William Groff rejected the churchs arguments that the suit should be dismissed on constitutional and other legal grounds in a series of rulings earlier this month.

Groff ruled, however, that the states three-year statute of limitation for lawsuits prevents the sisters from suing their father for the abuse.

One of the sisters lawyers, Cynthia Waldt of St. Paul, Minn., declined to comment on Groffs rulings Tuesday.

The churchs lawyer said he will ask Groff to reconsider.

Obviously, we feel badly for the two plaintiffs, but neither Watchtower (the churchs national governing body) nor the congregation are responsible for what happened, Donald Gardner of Manchester said.

Were confident that when Watchtower and the elders present their evidence, the facts will clearly show that neither (the church nor its elders) . . . knew of any child abuse until years after it had stopped, by which time the authorities already were involved.

The sisters suit stems from the case of Paul Berry, 46, formerly of Greenville, who was convicted of 17 counts of aggravated felonious sexual assault after a trial in 2000 in Hillsborough County Superior Court.

Berry was sentenced to serve 56 to 112 years in prison, one of the stiffest sentences ever imposed for a sexual assault case in New Hampshire. The state Supreme Court upheld his convictions in a ruling last year.

Berry was convicted of repeatedly assaulting his stepdaughter, Holly Berry, 24, of Berkeley, Calif., while she was between 4 and 10.

Berry also had been charged with assaulting his biological daughter, Heather Berry, 20, of Charlestown on several occasions while she was between 3 and 6. Prosecutors and Heather Berry dropped those charges after the conviction and sentence in her sisters case.

The Telegraph ordinarily doesnt identify victims of sexual abuse, but the Berry sisters chose to go public when they filed the suit in 2001.

Their suit names Berry, the Wilton congregation of Jehovahs Witnesses and the national organization, the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of Brooklyn, N.Y.

Around the time of Berrys trial, the sisters claim they learned their mother had told church elders of the abuse while it was happening, and asked for their help.

Their mother testified that the elders told her to keep quiet, pray more and strive to be a better wife.

Groff ruled that the girls cant sue the church for allegedly violating a state law that requires people to report suspected child abuse, because the law doesnt allow such claims. However, he ruled that the elders alleged failure to report the abuse or take other action on their mothers concerns can be used as evidence of negligence.

Groff ruled that any reasonable person would have understood the overwhelming risk of harm from sexual abuse, and the magnitude of that potential harm.

This rendered the elders conduct unreasonably dangerous in view of the horrific consequences to the plaintiff by not taking steps to report the abuse or properly counsel the plaintiffs mother, Groff wrote, assuming for arguments sake that the elders did conceal the abuse.

The prevention of sexual abuse of children is one of societys greatest duties, he continued. Clearly the social importance of protecting the plaintiff from her fathers continued brutal sexual abuse outweighs the importance of immunizing the defendants from extended liability.

The Watchtower Society had argued the church couldnt be held responsible for a failure to protect children from a parents abuse. The society also argued that allowing the suit to proceed would violate the constitutional protection of freedom of worship.

Groff disagreed, finding that religious beliefs dont excuse people from obeying state laws, including the law requiring people to report suspected child abuse.

The Jehovahs Witnesses also claimed the elders to whom Berrys mother reported the abuse were ministers of the church, and that state law protects the confidentiality of communications between the elders and members of the church just as a priest cant be forced to testify about matters disclosed during confession.

Groff found that issue requires further hearing, to decide whether elders were, in fact, ministers and whether their conversations with Berrys mother should be considered confidential. A hearing on that matter is scheduled for March 17, but is expected to be postponed, Gardner said.

Groff ruled in the churchs favor on a similar issue in a criminal sexual abuse case involving a Hollis man convicted of sexually assaulting several girls. In that case, Groff found that elders in the mans congregation couldnt be forced to testify about disclosures the man made while the elders were investigating abuse charges.

info Original content is © Copyright Religion News Blog. All rights reserved.
    Do not republish or repost. Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape

share this article Share this article

tag Related Articles


Comment Comment

Join Religion News Blog at Google+ to comment, share, and follow.

RSS Feed Follow Us


Religion News You May Like This As Well

Why are you not using Nozbe?

Don't you need to get things done?

Religion News Search Search Religion News Blog