Related
Advertisements *
Elsewhere
Subscribe: RSS
RNB's RSS feed What is this? |
Subscribe: Email
![]() |
![]() Subscribe by Email What is this? |
Most Popular
- Archbishop of Canterbury claims Christian doctrines is offensive to Muslims. Fails to note Islamic doctrine is offensive to Christians.
- Dutch church set up as a haven for smokers
- French Muslim minister: The burqa is a prison
- Parole panel denies compassionate release for Manson follower Susan Atkins
- Moonies Messiah injured in helicopter emergency landing
- How to cure anorexia with exorcisms
- Google, Yahoo, And The International Scientology Crime Syndicate
- Exorcism trial: sister claims woman can fake trances
- Church of Scientology banned from UK shopping centre
- Cook Islands: preacher takes Scientology to court
Jury rules against man in dispute over Texas evangelist at school
An Illinois man lost a federal lawsuit that accused his daughter’s school district of unconstitutionally endorsing religion when it allowed a Texas-based evangelist to lead anti-drug assemblies.
Robert Marsh was ordered to pay the Marion, Ill., school district’s court costs after a federal jury in Benton, Ill., last week found in favor of the district. Marsh filed the lawsuit on his daughter’s behalf in 2003, seeking damages from the district.
He was upset that evangelist Ronnie Hill of Fort Worth, Texas, was permitted to speak in district schools in November 2003 and that tickets to private events featuring Hill at a Marion church were distributed on school grounds.
But after the four-day trial, jurors found the district did not endorse religion or “foster excessive governmental entanglement with religion.”
Richard Whitney, an attorney for Marsh, declined to discuss the case Tuesday, saying “we have an agreement of the parties that we’re done trying this in the press.”
“We’re evaluating options as to where to go from here,” Whitney said.
Messages left by The Associated Press on Tuesday for Wade Hudgens, the superintendent of Marion schools, were not immediately returned. Merry Rhoades, an attorney for the district, said only that “the case is over, and we don’t want to belabor it.”
In his lawsuit, Marsh alleged on behalf of his daughter, Amanda — then a fourth-grader — that the school district arranged for Hill to provide secular anti-drug assemblies in the district’s schools. While in town, Hill also was to lead an evangelical crusade at Marion’s Cornerstone Community Church, which offered to give free pizza to children and teenagers who came for Hill’s sermon.
After Marsh sought an injunction to block Hill’s appearances in the schools, a federal judge allowed the assemblies to proceed but ordered Hill not to use the events to promote his appearances at the church.
Hill’s followers also were barred from handing out invitations at the schools to the Hill-led church revival that included free pizza parties. But on the day Hill was to speak at Amanda Marsh’s school, parents and community members there distributed tickets to the pizza party.
Witnesses later testified that a cafeteria worker had tickets, and students were openly doling them out, some with tickets pinned to their clothing.
According to the lawsuit, Marsh “strongly objects, as a taxpayer, to the expenditure of any tax monies for school-sponsored establishments of religion,” as well as to school-endorsed “events that aim to indoctrinate children with religious messages.”
In August 2006, federal judge James Foreman threw out the case at the school district’s behest, ruling the lawsuit was moot because the assemblies already had taken place and were unlikely to recur. He also found that the assemblies and ticket giveaways were constitutional.
U.S. District Judge G. Patrick Murphy reinstated the lawsuit at Marsh’s request in April 2007, ruling that the issue of damages remained unresolved and that evidence showed that Marsh’s daughter “was brought into `direct and unwelcome contact’ with the events prompted by the district’s invitation of Dr. Hill to speak.”
Share this
To share this page simply copy and paste one of these URL's:
Article and Site Tools
» PermaLink to: Jury rules against man in dispute over Texas evangelist at school Need a shorter link? You can remove everything after the final / » More news articles + news archive on Schools and Religion » More religion and cult news Subscribe (RSS / Email) [What is RSS?] » RSS News Feed - All Topics: Religion News Blog RSS Feed » RSS News Feed - Single Topic: Schools and Religion » Headlines by Email: Daily Religion News Blog Headlines |
More Article Tools
Bookmark / Tag: Del.icio.us Bookmark / Tag: Furl Save this article Email this article Print this article [Temporarily out of order] More Information Books about Schools and Religion Relevant books (and other goodies) |
About Religion News Blog
Religion News Blog (RNB), published by Apologetics Index, highlights news items and other resources on world religions, cults, religious sects, alternative religions and related issues. RNB's non-profit news clipping service is used by - among others - Christian apologists, countercult professionals, anticult organizations, cult experts, teachers, religion professionals, reporters and other researchers.



