Translate
Previous entry: Making a case for sacred meat
Next entry: Veil leads to Canadian Muslim’s soccer ejection
Get RNB via RSS
 |
RNB's RSS feed What is this? |
Get RNB via Email
 |
 Subscribe by Email What is this? |
Follow: Twitter
Most Popular
This Week:
- Guyana’s Jonestown suicide site gets plaque
- Gaddafi preaches Islam to Rome beauties
- Scientology practices ‘putting people at risk’
- Recession: Muslim schools in UK under threat of closure
- Australian senator tells Parliament of widespread criminal conduct within the Church of Scientology
- When a child dies, faith is no defense
- Muslim terrorists smuggle fatwas promoting Jihad out of secure UK prisons
- Techie Holy water and geeky bishops
- Israel Charges Extremist With Attempted Murder Of Messianic Family
- 1-year prison term for man who participated in cyber attack on Church of Scientology Web sites
U.S. justices deny review of conviction for bigamy
More articles on this topic: Writ had argued that such prohibitions are outdated; the man’s third ‘wife’ was 16
The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday denied a Utah polygamist’s request that it review his bigamy conviction.
The court’s refusal to hear an appeal by Rodney H. Holm leaves intact a May 2006 ruling by the Utah Supreme Court that found the polygamist could be prosecuted for bigamy even if his plural marriages did not receive state sanction.
Holm, a member of the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, took Ruth Stubbs as his third wife in 1998. At the time, he was 32 and Stubbs was 16. Stubbs later left the spiritual marriage.
A former police officer, Holm was convicted in August 2003 of two counts of unlawful sex with a minor and one count of bigamy. He spent a year in jail.
Holm’s writ argued that the Supreme Court’s 128-year-old Reynolds ruling, which banned polygamy, is outdated, given modern relationships and more recent rulings on liberty and privacy rights.
It challenged the right of states to regulate relationships that occur outside marriage, and said Utah unfairly targets polygamists in its bigamy prosecutions.
A dissent by Chief Justice Christine Durham found Utah’s bigamy statute unconstitutional, given the high court’s decision in Lawrence v. Texas, which prohibits government intrusion in intimate relationships involving consenting adults.
Individuals and groups who identify themselves as fundamentalist Mormons helped pay for Holm’s petition. They consider plural marriage a tenet of faith and hoped Durham’s dissent might help bring a challenge of polygamy bans before the high court.
“We do not agree that a man who doesn’t legally engage in marriage should be prosecuted and charged with bigamy,” said Mary Batchelor, a founding member of the advocacy group Principle Voices.
The mainstream Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints publicly disavowed polygamy in 1890 and excommunicates anyone who espouses or practices it.
Rod Parker, Holm’s attorney, acknowledged that Stubbs’ age was an obstacle, even though it was not a factor in his client’s bigamy conviction.
“There will be better opportunities in the future,” Parker said. “The issue was an important one that needs to be addressed.”
Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff said Monday that “it is very clear no one has the constitutional right to this type of behavior.” Added prosecutor Laura Dupaix, “We think it was the right thing to do because it involved a minor.”
She added, “We have been dealing with this case for so long, it’s nice to have it over – particularly because we think the Utah Supreme Court got it right.”
Fundamentalist Mormons now are looking to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals, which is deciding whether a Salt Lake County clerk properly denied a marriage license to a married couple who wanted to add a second wife. Analysts have said the case is unlikely to succeed because of its focus on the regulation of marriage, a right that clearly rests with states.
The FLDS church that Holm belongs to is based in Hildale, Utah, and Colorado City, Ariz., but has enclaves in Nevada, Texas, Colorado, South Dakota, Idaho and other states, as well as British Columbia. The church has 6,000 to 8,000 members.
Its president, Warren S. Jeffs, is scheduled to go on trial April 23 on two charges of being an accomplice to rape for arranging a marriage between an underage girl and a 19-year-old man.
What You Can Do From Here
|
Read More Articles On These Topics
Share, Blog About, Bookmark, or Email This Article
Subscribe
Read Another Article
Previous entry: Making a case for sacred meat Next entry: Veil leads to Canadian Muslim’s soccer ejection
RNB Homepage with latest headlinesFind Related Information
Find Related Books
|
Share This Article
To share this page simply copy and paste one of these URL's:
