Related
Translate
Previous entry: Attorneys: Jury in Terry Hornbuckle’s rape trial isn’t deadlocked
Next entry: Scientology: an election issue?
Get RNB via RSS
 |
RNB's RSS feed What is this? |
Get RNB via Email
 |
 Subscribe by Email What is this? |
Follow: Twitter
Most Popular
This Week:
- Guyana’s Jonestown suicide site gets plaque
- Scientology practices ‘putting people at risk’
- Recession: Muslim schools in UK under threat of closure
- Australian senator tells Parliament of widespread criminal conduct within the Church of Scientology
- World’s oldest ocean-going passenger ship, ministry ship Doulos, to stop sailing
- When a child dies, faith is no defense
- Israel Charges Extremist With Attempted Murder Of Messianic Family
- Scientology’s feet held to the fire in Australia: Struggle between a church and the state
- 1-year prison term for man who participated in cyber attack on Church of Scientology Web sites
- Australian police take up complaints about Scientology
[Aryan Brotherhood] Defendants facing death have right to confront witnesses
More articles on this topic: Hate GroupsLOS ANGELES – In a decision that could have wide-ranging implications on the U.S. court system, a federal judge ruled Thursday that two Aryan Brotherhood leaders convicted of murder and eligible for the death penalty have the right to confront their accusers during their upcoming sentencing hearing.
The ruling by U.S. District Judge Oliver O. Carter prevents the government from making its case for the execution of Barry “The Baron” Mills and Tyler “The Hulk” Bingham purely on documents, transcripts and third-person accounts by prison officials.
Although the ruling is not precedent since it did not originate with an appellate court, lawyers said it could be used as persuasive evidence in other capital cases on both the state and federal level.
“Although it’s not a binding precedent, it’s another arrow in the quiver,” said Mills’ attorney Dean Steward.
The 35-page ruling, issued by the judge in Santa Ana, came two days after a hearing in which he expressed concern about the impact his decision might have on interpretations of the U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Crawford vs. Washington, which involves the right of defendants to confront accusers.
On Thursday, the judge found the 2004 Supreme Court decision does extend to sentencing hearings in federal death penalty cases.
“Because the death penalty is uniquely different in its finality and severity, increased scrutiny is required at every step of the capital process to ensure that death is the appropriate penalty,” Carter wrote.
He said his ruling was “in line with maturing federal death penalty jurisprudence and its recognition of the need for increased reliability in capital sentencing.”
Thom Mrozek, spokesman for the U.S. Attorney’s office said he had not yet read the ruling and could not comment. He had said previously the government’s case during sentencing would be built largely on documentary evidence.
Mills and Bingham, two kingpins of the white supremacist prison gang, were convicted of murder, conspiracy and racketeering charges in crimes that go back as far as 30 years.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Stephen Wolfe argued at a Tuesday hearing that it would be difficult to find witnesses to testify. In an effort to document one alleged crime, Wolfe said he found one witness dead and two others missing.
However, the judge noted the government chose “to rely on proof of incidents that occurred over 30 years ago” and pointed to prosecutors seeking to use testimony of a dead witness who said Mills ordered him to murder another inmate in 1980.
“This is precisely the type of uncross-examined accusatory testimony that the Sixth Amendment protects against,” he said, noting it would be inadmissible even without the Crawford decision.
The judge said the government’s case will not be devastated by his ruling because much of its documentary evidence can be presented to the jury.
The sentencing phase of the trial is scheduled to begin Aug. 28.
What You Can Do From Here
|
Read More Articles On These Topics
Share, Blog About, Bookmark, or Email This Article
Subscribe
Read Another Article
Previous entry: Attorneys: Jury in Terry Hornbuckle’s rape trial isn’t deadlocked Next entry: Scientology: an election issue?
RNB Homepage with latest headlinesFind Related Information
Find Related Books
|
Share This Article
To share this page simply copy and paste one of these URL's:
