Judge throws out Quran oath lawsuit, saying suit lacks standing

CHARLOTTE, N.C. – A judge threw out an ACLU lawsuit aimed at allowing the use of non-Christian religious texts in courtroom oaths, saying the civil liberties group had no active case to argue.

Superior Court Judge Donald Smith, who is based in Raleigh, revealed his decision to lawyers in the case on Thursday. A written ruling was to follow.

The North Carolina chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union sued in Guilford County in July, saying it was acting on behalf of members statewide who prefer to swear courtroom oaths on religious texts other than the Bible.

No specific plaintiff was named in the original filing, and the ACLU added the name of Greensboro Muslim Syidah Mateen only after the suit had been filed, saying she was blocked from swearing an oath on the Quran during a 2003 court hearing.

Smith tossed out the case because there is no active controversy involving someone prohibited from using a text other than a Bible, ACLU lawyer Seth Cohen said Thursday.

“Of course, we’re very disappointed the judge did not reach the merits,” Cohen said. “We do believe there’s a case.”

He said he would consult with the state ACLU and its board about whether to appeal the decision or await a future opportunity to bring a fresh suit.

Noelle Talley, a spokeswoman for Attorney General Roy Cooper, declined to comment because the department had not received a signed order from Smith.

At issue is a state law that allows witnesses preparing to testify in court to take their oath either by laying a hand over a “Holy Scripture,” by saying “so help me God” without the use of a religious book or by using no religious symbols.

Asked to clarify whether Muslims could swear on the Quran, two top Guilford County judges said earlier this year that only the Bible could be used.

The ACLU’s suit argued that allowing Christians to swear on a Bible while denying Muslims, Jews, Hindus and others an opportunity to use their religious texts violates the First Amendment requirement that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion.”

The ACLU also asked the state’s Administrative Office of the Courts to intervene, but AOC director Ralph Walker said his office could not sanction the use of non-Biblical texts in courtrooms without action by the General Assembly or a court ruling.

Read Another Article

I will cure your cancer for 375 British Pounds
Alleged pope incarnate excommunicated

Related News Articles Topic(s): Church and State Subscribe to Religion News Blog updates Subscribe to Religion News Blog [What is this?] Get Religion News Blog's headline by Email [What is this?] Follow Religion News Blog at Twitter Find Related Information Use our custom search engines to find additional research resources on religions and cults: ApologeticsSearch.com: Search for apologetics articles, books, videos, and other research resources across 135 Christian apologetics websites and blogs. CounterCultSearch.com: Search for information about (religious) cults, cult-like organizations, and cults experts -- as well as paranormal-, New Age, and pseudoscientific claims -- across 260+ websites, blogs and forums dedicated to cult research, spiritual abuse, ex-cult counseling & support. Find Related Religion & Spirituality Books at Amazon.com Church and State Possibly related... or Most Popular Religion News Articles Kent Hovind: Evangelist arrested on federal charges Beast’s real mark devalued to ’616′ Muslim Woman Gives Sex Advice on Arab TV Michael Jackson Confirms Conversion to Islam Kent Hovind, ‘Dr. Dino,’ guilty on all counts The fall and rise of Carlton Pearson Search False prophet Harold Camping sets another date for rapture: May 21, 2011 Watch the film Theo van Gogh was murdered for Kent Hovind — Dr. Dino — sentenced to 10 years in prison

Search Religion News Blog